
PROUDLY
CANADIAN
On the 100th episode of Just One Q, Dominique chats with founding host Dr. Melissa Horne about the evolution of workplace DEI from 2020 to today. They explore the pitfalls of early performative initiatives, the challenges and rewards of treating DEI as an embedded technical skill, and how leaders can drive meaningful, systemic culture change.
Dominique: Hello, and welcome to Just One Q, the podcast where we explore the latest ideas in workplace belonging in conversation with thought leaders and experts.
Each episode, a guest and I dive into a question that highlights their area of expertise. The goal is to leave you with tools and insights you can use to make your workplace better and more human-friendly. I’m your host, Dominique Attrell. I’m an inclusion educator and advocate working for Dialectic, an inclusive workplace learning consultancy in lovely Guelph, Ontario, which is situated on the treaty lands and territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation and the traditional lands of the Chonnonton and Haudenosaunee Peoples.
Today marks our 100th episode of this podcast, and to celebrate, I’m bringing back Dr. Melissa Horne, the founding host of the show and the current advisor of organizational culture at the Ontario Veterinary College at the University of Guelph. Welcome, Melissa.
Melissa: Thank you so much for having me. It’s awesome to be back.
Dominique: It’s great to see you. And, today we’re gonna talk about so the transformations that we’ve seen in DEI, how we talk about DEI, and most importantly, how we put it into practice since 2020 when you first launched this podcast. So we’ll be doing a bit of a DEI then and now, and exploring the question, what works and what doesn’t in DEI practice today?
This episode will be probably a little bit more chatty and a little bit less structured than we’re used to, but our goal is always to bring those insights and some usable things, so we hope that you come along with us for the mother of all episodes. And before we dive into our conversation, I wanna take a moment just to highlight what we’ve accomplished jointly on this podcast with our lovely guests.
So the show’s strength has always been its ability to bridge high-level and complex topics from philosophy to social work to organizational psychology to legal frameworks with the more practical human-centered workplace strategy. And it has been our goal to platform worthy voices and bring practical insights from their work directly to our listeners.
Across the past 100 episodes, we’ve hosted best-selling authors like Humble The Poet, the author of Unlearn, and Elaine Lin Herring, author of Unlearning Silence. We’ve had world-renowned workplace DEI leaders like Aiko Bethea of Rare Coaching and Consulting and the Dare to Lead communities of Brené Brown Education and Research Group.
We’ve had Dr. Ludmila Praslova, who is the author of The Canary Code and a hugely influential researcher in workplace neuroinclusion. We’ve had many academics who translate their research into practical workplace improvements, scholars like Dr. Peter Huang in mathematics, law, and economics, Dr. Suzanne Wertheim in linguistics, Dr. Joel Davis Brown in queer studies and leadership theory. Dr. Steve Bland in philosophy and cognitive science, and Dr. Sara Kafashan in psychology and pedagogy, just to name a few. Um, we’ve also had a bunch of DEI practitioners on this show. We’ve highlighted frontline practitioners who are doing the gritty work of putting these theories into practice in DEI, HR, and people leadership.
And we’ve talked to folks on the front lines in marine transportation, in higher education, innovators in marketing and creative media, and advisors in even municipal governance who are evaluating public policy through an equity lens. So we’ve seen a bunch of people working in a bunch of different industries and sectors, uh, grapple with how to implement DEI.
And, if you are tuning into this podcast for the first time, one of the best ways to browse past episodes is on our website at dialectic.solutions/podcast, or you can just Google us and hit the link to the Dialectic site, and there you’ll see episodes organized by year.
And you can read a little bit more about guests and episode themes to make your selection, rather than just kind of scrolling through on Spotify or Apple Podcast. So Melissa, when we started planning this episode, we talked about what we’ve learned and how all of these conversations that we’ve been having and our own work fits into a sort of arc from 2020 to now.
And I think that the awareness of how things have shifted over recent years is actually really instructive to how we’re doing belonging work. So let’s dig into it. Um, I wanna time travel back to 2020. How were we thinking about and talking about DEI then?
Melissa: So I think we had sort of two massive cataclysmic moments happening in 2020.
So, first we had the COVID-19 pandemic, which totally upended and disrupted the workplace and made us really think about, um… You know, we had this massive and very quick shift to work from home. We had to start thinking about things like caregiving responsibilities. We had to think about how we communicate with each other.
We were working across different time zones, and how do we, you know, meeting equity and, and So we had this massive shift. We had to think about, you know, people started to think, you know, productivity. We had this sort of then looking at frontline versus the office workers.
So that started to raise a whole bunch of issues around workplace equity. And then, um, very, very shortly after, we had the Black Lives Matter movement. Which sort of made folks have to reconcile with the way that institutions and the systems that we operate in and the organizations that we work in replicate and have replicated historic and present-day inequities for Black and racialized folks.
And so, together these really made workplaces question, what are we doing, and what do we do about it? And, where do we go from here?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um-
Dominique: And those two big moments were definitely connected and had a lot of interplay. Like, they really did overlap. I remember, um, being at a BLM protest, and people were hesitant to go, and we were all, you know, masked to the hilt, and some families were deciding whether or not they were gonna be joining just on the, you know, the basis of COVID.
So it s- was like this mega moment of these two things colliding and the injustice that, uh, Black communities in particular were feeling as a result of COVID, like lack of access to vaccines and, like, poorer health outcomes and all of these things that were also driving the protest movement too, right?
Melissa: Absolutely. And I think, you know, COVID highlighted and really pointed to sort of what, what Black folks have been saying for years, how systemic racism operated. And we could see it playing out in real time.
Dominique: Yep.
Melissa: So, you know, I think all across major institutions, folks were thinking about, okay, what, what do we do? And how do we start to repair? And this is a moment. How do we meet it?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And we were working together at Dialectic which is a workplace learning company, and we were also trying to grapple with these similar questions, right? You know, we were trying to think about how to develop a product that could meet this moment, um, sort of answer the questions that companies were asking.
What do we do? How do we… you know
Dominique: Mm-hmm…
Melissa: is there training? What does this look like? How could we help, uh, everyday companies train their staff around anti-racism? We were also thinking about, how do we ensure that we’re not continuing to replicate inequity? So how do we ensure that the training is informed by lived experience, and how do we focus on doing this work ethically and in true partnerships that create economic value for Black and racialized experts?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And so, this is kind of where the podcast was born, in this moment.
Dominique: Right, just trying to kind of forge connections, have the conversation to figure out how to move forward. And then of course, as a result of a lot of these conversations, this is also where Learning Snippets was born. And Learning Snippets, I don’t talk about Learning Snippets a lot on the podcast, even though, you know this was started as sort of a Learning Snippets podcast originally.
But Learning Snippets is basically a library of scenario-based microlearning lessons that is delivered to people’s inboxes, and it puts them straight into a scenario where they get to choose how to respond, and then they experience the social consequence of that response. So it’s sort of what we came up with as a team as a product to meet that moment. And, we have learned, you know, it’s been a fantastic way to teach people relational skills, including, the avoidance of microaggressions or responding to racist moments or being an effective ally in a safe and shame-free environment. Because it is sort of privately done on your computer. You know, you’re not in a room having to grapple with the questions before you’re ready or before you’ve had a little bit of practice. And it takes that bit of practice to handle those moments gracefully, and this allows people to just be prepared and to kind of prepare them then for further team conversations.
So this was definitely, you know, in direct response to what companies were doing at the time. Do you remember, Melissa, like, what was the demand like, and what were businesses specifically asking for?
Melissa: I think folks were trying to meet the moment. You know, there was intense public pressure on organizations to adopt anti-racist policies.
We have to think about this is the first time outside of, you know, the walls of academia where in everyday parlance we’re hearing things about privilege, positionality.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um, you know, anti-racism is now sort of what we constantly talk about, but, this was, you know, left in academic papers.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And so folks were trying to think about, how do we translate these sort of more conceptual theories or things that typically within the realms of academics and also activists as well into our workplace so that, whether you’re on the front lines or whether you are a knowledge worker, that you can actually put these words into practice.
So what does it mean to be anti-racist? What does a microaggression look like? Um, so there’s all these, these terms coming around and we’re trying to figure out how do we show folks what this actually looks like in the workplace?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: Um, you know, businesses were creating, very rapidly, DEI statements and commitments. You know, there’s a lot of sense that folks were jumping into anti-racism initiatives in the workplace, sometimes and maybe oftentimes performatively.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um, there was a burst of hiring for DEI specific roles and positions. There were ERGs, employee resource groups,
Dominique: Yeah
Melissa: um, forming or maybe seeing renewed attention. There were committees, so DEI committees as well. So, lots of learning and development opportunities, many of which were focused on the Black experience in society, in the workplace. And so I think, you know, at that time, folks were relying on, um, folks with lived experience and to come and share their experiences.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: Um, so this was often speaker style. Folks were hosting large company-wide trainings, usually, you know, one or two hours. And, you know, we would call them, like, one and done, right? So,
Dominique: Yeah, yeah …
Melissa: Here, we’ve brought in this large keynote speaker, they’ve spoken to us, we, we’ve…
we’re good, right?
Dominique: Yeah …
Melissa: moving on. Um, and so, a lot of critiques of wokeness also, right? That were sort of popping up there as well.
Dominique: Yeah. I remember that too, like, very early on as a response to some of the workplace training that was happening. There was definitely, like, a bubbling culture war was brewing from the very beginning. And this all really happened very quickly it felt like. Um, like overnight there were just all of these commitments and all of this training happening and, like, speakers who wouldn’t have previously had access were just, like, able to build careers on speaking engagements in companies.
But there was also that, that pushback piece, right? Like, what do you remember about the pushback that was pretty immediate at that time?
Melissa: Right. So we also then, you know, so in response to Black Lives Matter, then we have sort of the emergence of White Lives Matter. We had Blue Lives Matter. We have All Lives Matter, right?
Dominique: Yeah, yeah.
Melissa: So, you know, the folks who were probably, uh, you know, feeling the shame and blame and if they sort of thought about it or maybe reflecting or uncomfortable with the idea of privilege and all these, again, these, these terms that they were being confronted with in the first time, there was massive pushback, right?
They were presented in very abstract theoretical terms and rather than translated into the lived experiences and practical applications. Yeah. A lot of folks did not see themselves represented in DEI training, and turned away from it.
So I think we lost a lot of folks who might otherwise have actually come along for the ride.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: But I think the way that it was framed, and again, because this happened all so fast, like, we were taking stuff straight from academia and trying to implement it, right? Or, I say we, proverbial we, that’s what folks were doing, right?
Because that’s where the literature was, that’s what we had to draw on, and so, the pushback. So for as many folks who were hopping on board and wanting to get involved, we also had sort of I think an equal amount of folks who were really feeling alienated and didn’t see themselves represented in the training.
Dominique: Yeah. There’s definitely the heavy language of oppression and opp-
Melissa: Yes …
Dominique: systems of oppression or systemic racism and all of that did certainly leave some people behind. And then there was also, it was a kind of a narrower focus as well on race at that time, which also did crowd out people who were maybe not racialized but did have experiences of oppression.
And so it was, like, not always the most nuanced conversation in those early days, and I think that did get better. And you know, the focus has shifted gradually to intersectionality and to other forms of oppressed identities and all of that. But, there was definitely that, that pushback. And I remember- This became such a huge factor in how organizations were then thinking about their DEI training efforts.
You know, there was a lot of fear about that small but vocal minority of sort of resisters who were in sessions flipping the logic of oppression. Talking about reverse racism and things like that, for example. And, I remember a moment where that opposition or the pushback kinda came to a fever pitch in the Canadian context, um, around 2023.
There was a suicide of a white retired principal from the Toronto District School Board who had claimed that his mental illness stemmed from a disagreement that he had at a virtual DEI training session in 2021, and that really shook people. It shook facilitators, it shook DEI companies, and people who were trying to do that work because it became almost like a liability.
Like the, you know, obviously that is not the goal, is to create negative experiences for, for participants. And when you have somebody claiming that they were so deeply affected negatively by this that they couldn’t live any longer, that was… It was just so dramatic, and it did kind of, um, I remember sort of pausing and,
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: Letting that sink in and thinking, you know, is anything that we are presenting potentially going to trigger some backlash that’s that severe. And, and then of course there was, like, the much broader sociopolitical pushback. So there was a surge of alt-right interest and, uh, kind of a political shift to the right in Canada and in the US, and of course elsewhere in the world as well.
And there were some massive legal and regulatory shifts, which we’ve talked a lot about on this show with our guests in the last couple of years especially. So things like in the United States having the big, you know, affirmative action rollbacks, legislative bans on public DEI funding. There’ve been corporate budget cuts, and organizations have been sort of pivoting away from explicit DEI branding with varying levels of conserving the core DEI, uh, sort of energy, sometimes funneling it into, you know, across programs but in a quieter way, and sometimes just scrapping things altogether depending on sort of the goals and the culture of an organization.
So there has been a, a swing, and we have talked about this with guests previously. But, it is dramatically changing from, from 2020 till now, you know, the way that we think about, DEI and how we can actually practice it. So I wanna talk a little bit more about some of the critiques of DEI because, while I don’t agree with resistors in the sessions, some of the critiques that are leveled against DEI or have been in the past few years have created a really important opportunity for us to build something that’s more robust and effective and more welcoming to everybody, yeah, just more effective. So, what do you think of those critiques? What are the ones that stand out to you as, as having some, some resonance?
Melissa: Yeah. So, if we think about where the training went and it really focused on sort of these interpersonal, right? So it, it went to the one-on-one.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: How can I be a better colleague or reflecting on maybe past interactions with folks, right? So I think that’s really interesting because that’s not exactly what BLM was asking for. And, and so I think, you know, a lot of folks are saying that while it’s important to understand unconscious bias, it’s important to understand microaggressions, and that’s where I think we started to see people turn away. No one wanted to see themselves as racist, right? It really created a lot of cognitive dissonance.
You have Sharon Nyangweso who is the founder and CEO of Quake Lab,
Dominique: Yeah…
Melissa: has argued, often that these one-off unconscious bias trainings were damaging, right? Because, one, if not done well, then they leave folks, like everyone more harmed.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: But also, folks were just saying if we just teach unconscious bias, then we’re good and we don’t actually have to look at systemic change and address real institutional biases, right?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: So there’s a lot of critiques and I think, you know, 2023 maybe, 2024, ’25, there became a lot more critiques from inside the house, right?
So as we mentioned, Sharon Nyangweso from Quake Lab, but also Lily Zheng, if you follow them, they post furiously often on LinkedIn. Lily has written a lot about the over-reliance on short-term, you know, sort of flashy fixes in this post-2020 DEI era. And again, Lily would also say that organizations defaulted again to these one-off unconscious bias trainings, right? Check-the-box workshops rather than doing sort of the long-term structural work, which is required to really change operational processes and power dynamics. And, if we go back to what Black Lives Matter was asking for us, was not that we do microaggressions and focus on that. They were highlighting these brutal, systemic, and long-standing institutional oppressive practices that have disproportionately impacted Black and racialized folks, right? So, these critiques started to come out saying, you know, this training has to be done thoughtfully, and it has to be done so that we’re actually not harming the folks that we’re intending to help, I think on both sides.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um-
Dominique: Absolutely. Absolutely. There… Like, Lily Zheng’s book, Deconstructing DEI, pulls all of these into one place if you’re looking to read a bit more about that critique.
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: There are many, many angles that are covered in that book, and, the ones that resonate to me too is that DEI initiatives were really frequently focused on, um, individual language or personal belief or identities instead of those larger systemic pieces, so like inequitable hiring, opaque promotion pathways, unsupportive leave policies, the things that really do affect people’s everyday experience of the workplace.
And there was a lot of, as a result of that focus, it was often shame-based.
There was,
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: You know, treating privileged groups in purely negative terms which, you know, you could say was overdue and people needed to hear it, but it also did foster resentment and spark some of that backlash that we were talking about.
And there are better ways of positioning this so that it has more traction. One of the ways that Lily Zheng talks about it now is through the lens of fairness, which I think is really effective and
Melissa: Mm-hmm…
Dominique: Went over much better. But yeah, you know, some of those practices eroded trust and accountability, and there’s a moment now to sort of pivot and rethink what we’re doing.
I’m gonna ask you, you know, what specific challenges in terms of that DEI piece have you seen in your, in your current context in higher education?
Melissa: Yeah. I mean, I think we really struggle between the idea that we still need to train people
Dominique: Mm …
Melissa: Right? And what does that training look like and what does it hope to achieve?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Is it tone setting? Is it sort of baseline setting? But ,we know that higher education continues to have access pathways and inequities, right? And that’s across the board in terms of the students who get in and the challenges and supports that they have while they’re here, for faculty as well.
You know, and I think if we go back to when I came on board almost four years ago, we were still sort of caught in that moment, institutionally was, you know, there’s a feeling of if people knew better, then they would do something better, right? So,
Dominique: Right…
Melissa: But, I also think, we’re sort of at that, like, pivotal… There’s sort of that teetering moment where people’s enthusiasm was also fading, and people were tired.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I mean, we were still in the throes or sort of near the tail end of COVID, and so there was other things that I think were also like people were physically tired, mentally tired.
And, so on the one hand, I think I kind of came at a really interesting time where, like, there wasn’t… folks weren’t looking so much for those statements. We’ve kind of moved past that. And, we actually had an opportunity, I think, to think critically about what we actually wanted, at least at the Ontario Veterinary College, what did we want diversity, equity, inclusion, belonging to be, right?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um, we did definitely start with some training, around sort of just at least creating like, what does it actually mean? What does a microaggression look like, and how do we respond? Like, but really actionable, practical, right?
We moved from that, that like sort of more,
Dominique: Finish line
Melissa: abstract-
Dominique: Theory …
Melissa: yeah, to like here’s what it actually looks like in your day to day.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: And build some of that empathy, right? Like, what you may not realize is that your colleagues are facing these types of experiences.
So we, we did that. But I think I really thought about how do we, move from these individual interventions, which we kind of knew were starting to not work, to actually answering the call to make systemic change.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: Um, and I think what that meant is that for a few years, at least here in my work, it meant that the work seemed to look like it was underground or that it had gone away.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: But it was really just about, it’s just less visible, right? You just don’t see posters for training and workshops. So that’s why I think we’ve seen a lot of the places, is that it hasn’t gone away, it’s just that we’ve moved from these more visible performative things, that, to the actual really hard work, and that takes time and it’s a bit more quiet, right?
Yeah. ‘Cause you’re building coalitions, you’re gathering folks.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um, you’re finding the champions and you’re plotting out how do we change these practices, policies, and procedures.
Dominique: Yeah. Can you give maybe an example of something that you’ve done that is an initiative that is not training?
Melissa: We have a sliding scale food market here that maybe one might not think, on the face of it is about DEI. But, this is one of those things where we’re looking at, okay, some parts of the system on campus are failing folks. And, food security is a growing concern.
And, you know, if we think about how do we embed stuff we work, we have a market that happens every week in our cafeteria that the time is accessible for folks who, regardless of they’re sort of working the day shift or the night shift, they could come.
That is open to any member of the community regardless of their financial status or station. And that provides fresh produce for folks. And so, you know, we thought a lot about access. We thought a lot about inclusion. We offer culturally diverse foods. We partner with different student organizations around campus, around different not just cultural and religious events, but also just in, in general we, we try to bring a lot of diverse foods to the market.
So those are small things that are maybe not what we would have traditionally thought about DEI, but are part of, like, you know, building this into the way that we do things here.
Dominique: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. And that’s a great example because it is so far outside of what we would have considered to be DEI activities in 2020.
But if DEI isn’t… If it’s more than the training, and if it’s not specifically about feelings or awareness or statements, we really do have to rethink what it means, and that’ll be different in different contexts and vary according to the needs of the people that you’re serving. Sharon Nyangweso, who we’ve spoken about already, and many others have, and Lily Zheng, of course, have pushed to reframe DEI more as a technical skill,
Melissa: Mm-hmm …
Dominique: And argue that it needs to be embedded into daily operations, policies, and system design. So this would mean almost like a life cycle analysis, carefully evaluating existing programs and policies. So things like hiring procedures, promotion pathway, compensation packages, benefits, professional development opportunities or, you know, mentorship and leadership opportunities. So,
Melissa: Yeah, I was gonna say one of the first things,
Dominique: Yeah …
Melissa: Yeah, one of the first things I did when I got here was we looked at our DVM or doctor of veterinary student, their whole… their journey. So, points from the moment that they submit an application to the moment they graduate, and looked at it from, we brought this lens of, okay, so what, what kind of information do they get?
Who do they get it from? What might they need? And we realized that during the admissions process, international students were receiving their admissions kind of late in the cycle, and then having to start right away.
And so they didn’t have enough time always to apply for loans and for housing, right? So we identified that as a gap and were able to adjust the admissions process, right? So, as you’re saying, you’re looking at, like, these different touch points and where the opportunities that we can actually make changes that will benefit a whole bunch of people.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And, and it… that, again, on its face, if we go back to 2020, would not necessarily have seemed like sort of a,
Dominique: Yeah …
Melissa: a DEI thing that, that maybe most people were thinking about.
Dominique: For sure. Yeah. I mean, what are the challenges for you of implementing DEI more as a technical skill or, like, in a more embedded way?
Melissa: Yeah, so I think, I mean, it’s kinda funny because, we said it’s not necessarily about training, but I think it’s training in a different way, right?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: So it’s less about focusing on how can we shift people’s individual beliefs or behaviors, ’cause that’s really hard to measure, but it’s about teaching people then to do these, as you said, these life cycle analysis, these types of activities, right?
So when I, I came on board, I worked with the entire team and actually got their input, and they started to see, oh, you know, maybe I could change this because here’s how it would benefit more people.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: So I think the challenges are is actually getting people, if we’re calling this as a technical skill, is sort of this upskilling, right?
So how do we do that? It does take time to walk people through certain processes that they do every day and ask them to think, “How could we make this more equitable,” right? And, and if we think about it like that, then it’s really hard to think about, like, what do I prioritize? What, what do we do first, right?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I would say that even though there’s this flurry of hiring, there’s still not more people. DEI departments are still usually a department of one, so it’s around resourcing and capacity. So even if we do want to train more people on this or get them, it still takes time to work your way through an organization and get folks upskilled.
It’s coordination. And, that means that, sometimes if there’s sort of a one or two-person team, that you get bottlenecks, right, around access to that expertise. So those are the challenges, but also I think we’re in an exciting time where, if we think about it as a technical skill, then it’s something that everyone can be trained on and start to embed in their day-to-day, right?
Folks are learning how to adopt AI as a technical skill.
Dominique: Right.
Melissa: Folks are… You know, we’re learning all sorts of things. It’s just about how to be intentional about it.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Yeah.
Dominique: Well, so you’re pointing toward, you know, training or empowerment of individual people across your organization,
Melissa: Yes.
Dominique: To do DEI work in all of their projects and programs, or to kind of adopt it as a lens or a general culture. So rather than focusing on changing people’s beliefs or we’re trying to actually fix how the workplace operates in a more systemic way. And, what are the points for you at which you’re training people to do this?
Or how… What does that look like?
Melissa: So, I think one of the good things is that I think a lot of people are thinking more about access, they are thinking about equity, they’re thinking about fairness.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: They’re thinking about how do we actually… You know, they’re starting to identify groups that might have been marginalized, and coming and saying, “We want to solve this problem, and here’s what we’re thinking about doing, how do we do this?”
Dominique: Right.
Melissa: And so, that’s great because folks are already bringing that work to me. And then that’s the opportunity when I can say, “Okay, here, let’s work through this together. Here’s how I would approach it.”
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And actually, you’ve probably thought about a lot of these different things.
So,
Dominique: Yeah … you
Melissa: know, so we kind of.
Dominique: You get to just sort of hand it back to them and be like I’m not gonna do this for you as a department of one. I’m going to support you in thinking through this, and then you can go ahead and, and do,
Melissa: Yeah.
Dominique: Yeah. Okay.
Melissa: Yeah, so it’s, it’s great because I think folks still kind of rely on that person as, like, the gatekeeper. But I,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I’m not, right? I actually rely on folks because you know your process, you are more of an expert in this area of work, but I can work with you.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And then if we do it together, then you start to build that capacity as well, and they start to see the opportunities, right?
Dominique: Yeah. Are there any, like, tools or strategies that you give to people who come to you who are thinking of you still as the gatekeeper of, of DEI things, who wanna do the right thing but who maybe don’t have experience employing DEI as a technical skill in their role?
Like, where do you start with somebody like that? What do you tell them?
Melissa: Well, I actually say, like, ” you’re already thinking about this,” right?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: So reminding folks that, again, I think we’re still hung up on, like, what we used to think it was, and I say, like, “The very fact that you’re thinking about this is, like, you’re doing this work.”
And I don’t even know if we continue to call it DEI work. I just, I’m not even sure if that’s what we’re calling it. We do, but I say, like, “You are doing this work.”
There’s a really good tool that Tidal Equality developed, and it’s called the equity sequence. And so I took the training and it’s something that I would encourage folks in my position and maybe other leaders in organizations to take. It’s online, asynchronous, takes about two to three hours, and it asks you five questions around a, project, an initiative, something that you’re doing, and it asks you how could you make it more equitable. And I think it’s really great because it’s a very simple tool. There are five very simple questions, and you can teach other folks in your organization how to ask those questions, and you can bring people together to do that. So I think, we still very much use sort of a human-centered design approach as well. So,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: If someone’s asking me to help them do something for someone else, another group, I say, “Well, have we asked that other group what they need as well?”
Right? So we still… And so there’s more collaboration, and we’re bringing folks along as well, right? So we can’t forget, we’re not just sort of doing these things and hoping that it works for the group. We’re still very much bringing folks in as well. And so I would say that a lot of what I do, and I was pushed very much to do, folks were wondering why I never did a DEI committee.
And then,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: And, I couldn’t find any research that showed that a DEI committee actually worked. You know, there was nothing in the literature that said, “Here are the benefits.” There’s lots on how to form one. And instinctively, and, and also I was doing some work around liberatory design, which I know you also.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: And that committees replicate the same hierarchical culture, colonial structures. They require a lot of work usually by the folks who have been historically and currently oppressed. And so I said, “Well, let’s, let’s form working groups around certain issues. That way folks who are interested and passionate and who are maybe impacted or will be impacted have a say in it, and then we disband.”
Dominique: Mm.
Melissa: So, and then other folks, as we’re doing this work, get to see how it’s done, and then they can go and build on it. I still guide and I still support. I’m here. I’m a resource. That is what my job is to do. But I think as people do it, they realize it’s actually, it demystifies the whole thing, right?
It actually
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Makes it practical and tangible,
Dominique: Yep.
Melissa: And meaningful ’cause they can see, oh, I made this shift, and now it’s impacted X number of people and made their lives incredibly better.
We were able to make this small shift, and it’s actually made a huge impact.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: So.
Dominique: Yeah, I think that’s so important to do that demystification piece because,
Melissa: Yeah.
Dominique: It can be really daunting. It was easy to make a statement. It was easy to hire a speaker, and then all of a sudden we’re pivoting to, oh, actually, DEI is a technical skill. And people are like, “Ah, there’s no, you know, consensus necessarily on how to proceed with this. I don’t have a degree in this.”
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: Um, nor do most people, you know? And it’s, so we’re inventing this practice as we go along, or it’s, hyper-specific to the context that we’re working in. So, the idea that you can use simple tools, I think, is really important. Like the five-question framework that you mentioned, and also this idea of building coalitions of people who are affected and impacted so that instead of having a stale DEI committee that’s processing everything or acting like a gatekeeper,
Melissa: Mm-hmm …
Dominique: you’re actually, you’re actually doing the, the work of, like, building these little micro-communities around issues that matter to people, and then they can do the work and disband.
Melissa: Yeah. And I have another great example. We wanted to create a multi-faith and quiet space.
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And so I put out a call. So, it’s located sort of right in our main building. Called the folks to join a working group to help design the space. And so, we wanted representatives from our student veterinarians, our graduate students, and faculty and staff. And, I think I just asked, like, “Why are you interested?” And we have, you know, we have terms of reference, we would meet as a group to talk about the design of the space, how it would be used amongst the community, how could we make sure that it was accessible. And so we met maybe four or five times and really,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: It was around, like, the aesthetics, but also, like, could we have food? Because a lot of, faiths and groups gather around food. Yeah. So was that something, right? But, and then also we wanted to make, so it was multi-faith but also a quiet space.
So if you needed a moment for quiet reflection or if for accessibility needs you needed a place for quiet, that that was also open to you. And we created rules around, like, could you book it, and how long could you book it for? Because, again, we wanted to make sure it was accessible. And so that group met for probably around six weeks,
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: Um, maybe and then the rest of it was on Teams. And then, we now only have to come together if there are large questions, right? And that’s it. But, that met a real need in our community because, where we are on campus, it’s really hard to get across to the other multi-faith spaces during certain times of year for folks for certain religions where there’s daily prayers or timed prayers. And so we created a space so that folks here could access it. So, we met a need of the community. We ensured that there are multiple diverse voices represented on this committee, and folks got to self-select in it.
Dominique: Yep.
Melissa: And then we respected their time and said we will only meet around these specific things, and then we meet as questions come up that the committee needs to.
And that’s it. So there are ways that you can meet the needs of your organization efficiently and that have impact,
Dominique: Mm …
Melissa: um, and I couldn’t have done that with a DEI committee. Like, that,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Would’ve taken so long.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I’m sure we would’ve gotten hung up, but, like, we kinda swarmed this project and then we meet as needed.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Um, so there’s nothing, you know, but committees have all these rules and regulations and I don’t know. It just,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Never felt right.
Dominique: Yeah. I love the idea, too, of the process itself, like the group itself, the formation of the group working together as a liberatory process. And,
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: You mentioned liberatory design a little bit ago, and I’m just gonna pull that out again because to me this is something that comes to mind too in this new way of doing things.
So liberatory design is a problem-solving or design practice that kinda shifts the relationship between people who have the power to design something or make a decision and those who are impacted. And it really supports agency for the people who are influenced by any design decision. And you can go online and look this up, and there’s a whole bunch of mindsets and practices that are associated with liberatory design. So an example would be a focus on building relational trust.
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: Um, and so really kind of that coalition piece that you’re talking about is built in.
Practicing self-awareness, what do I know? What is my position in this work? What are the limits of my capability or decision-making power in this sense? It’s also recognizing and naming oppression, so, like, not being silent on why we’re doing this, what we’re trying to tackle. How is oppression or historic harm gonna show up? How can we approach this to sort of mitigate some of that? And then that, you know, working through fear and discomfort is another idea that comes from liberatory design. So just not being too shy to do the work and being in coalition with people who are different and trying to push a path forward.
So, all of it represents just a new mindset for how to undertake a project. And,
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: It’s something that you can use to underpin everything that you do within your organization. And it sounds like you’ve found a really neat way of doing that without drowning in committee work.
Melissa: Yeah. And I mean, none of this is easy, right? ‘Cause you are working within a very hierarchical stru- like, with, you know, that,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Is built on processes, right? So
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I don’t wanna say this is easy, but, what I’m saying is that I think where we once had sort of revered, like, only certain people have this knowledge and can do this work.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: I, I want it… yes, obviously up to date, I live and breathe this, and not everyone does. But, there’s tools out there that everyone has the capacity and can do it.
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: And, if we train people and empower people to do it, and if we sort of, project by project make it so that it is everyone’s responsibility, if we think about, like, health and safety, right? Like, I’m not a health and safety expert, but I’m trained to know that, like, certain things, right? So we just, start to embed it as part of the culture. Yeah. That this is something that we do. That we ask these questions, we think about these things, or we know who to go to if we have questions, right?
So, I’m a resource. I think, was it Lily Zheng or may have said that, like, you know, we know we’ve done it when we’ve worked ourselves out of our job and
Dominique: Mm.
Melissa: And I don’t know if we ever will, but I think the goal is that, I don’t want to hold this all.
And it Yeah. Shouldn’t all be me, because I lack perspective, and I don’t know everyone’s experiences, and everyone brings something useful to this work. And so we just, we need to empower folks and show them how that this is something that they actually can do. You don’t have to have a, as you mentioned, a degree or any specialized knowledge. You can do it if you ask the right questions and you bring the right people together. Sometimes it does take a little bit longer on the front end, but I guarantee you, you will not have hiccups on the other end, because a lot of people will then raise their hand and say, “Hey, you forgot about me. You forgot about this.” And then you have to go back and redesign the whole thing. So if you take the time at the beginning,
Dominique: Yeah …
Melissa: to include those different voices and perspectives in true consultation, right? Not just like lip service, but truly build something with the folks that you wanna support, then I think, you end up with a better outcome and it actually, it expedites the process over the long haul.
Dominique: Yeah. For sure. And I will just say a word about at Dialectic on the training side of things, things have shifted as well to reflect this new type of skill. And so what that looks like is a bigger emphasis on developing core competencies that support DEI and these skills are sort of, like, organic and embedded within good leadership practices.
Melissa: Mm-hmm.
Dominique: So when you have leaders who understand that DEI isn’t a separate committee or a separate line item, and that it’s like in sort of the tissue of what they’re doing, it’s inseparable from being a good leader, you can foster some of those skills a little bit more easily. So it’s things like shifting from risk-avoidant behavior toward curiosity and asking people what they need, welcoming feedback on processes without taking it as a personal attack, or taking time to listen to people and seeking their perspectives on which rules or processes or arbitrary standards are creating hurdles for them.
So these are things that can be worked into leadership training as emerging leaders are coming into themselves, this is sort of the foundational stuff that we have to start to put in place so that once they get into positions to make decisions, people are just sort of automatically assuming this is part of the culture and part of what their job is, right?
Melissa: Yeah. And I think the other thing too is that we have to recognize that we know we’re not in a utopian place. Microaggressions haven’t gone away. Discrimination hasn’t gone away. These are still here. But, part of the work is actually to make these processes more transparent and if we think about DEI as a technical skill in the way that we work, it also has to be sort of, in our common parlance, right?
So we have to sort of have these norms around what is and what isn’t acceptable, and then what do we do about it. And so I think part of the work also for folks, you know, coming up is to make these processes more transparent.
Dominique: Mm…
Melissa: To make them more trauma-informed, to ensure that we’re not re-harming folks who do speak up who do experience issues of racism and sexual and gender-based violence.
That folks who do experience really harsh workplace things, that we’re actually not re-traumatizing and re-harming
Dominique: Yeah…
Melissa: Through the processes. So I think, that’s another area where we do it, and that we have a culture where we speak up, right? Where we name these things and we do practice what were doing early on around sort of, like, calling out where-
Dominique: Yeah
Melissa: you know, we are practicing that early training. Because, that is still valuable as well. So I don’t wanna get, you know, I don’t wanna think these things aren’t happening. Um, but part of the work is actually to make this process better and to make it part of how we do things, right? We have to have, we’ve been talking about how those early interpersonal interventions tried to shift people’s beliefs and behaviors. We still need to work on that too. You know, And similarly in hospitals they have a patient safety culture, right?
Dominique: Right.
Melissa: Where, where anyone needs to speak up if they see something that is happening that could harm either the medical practitioner or the patient, right? So, you know, if someone accidentally grabs the wrong vial, we’re not silent, right? Because, we’re afraid that we might hurt that person’s feelings.
We call that out and say, “Hey, can we double-check that?”
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Right? And that’s a shared responsibility. That’s everyone’s responsibility. We wanna create that sort of same type of culture around all the other isms in our workplaces. And that means that we have to build trust in the system and we have to have better processes for reporting and, and for dealing with that kind of thing as well.
Dominique: Yeah, absolutely. Well, Melissa, I’m gonna put you in the hot seat and I’m gonna try
Melissa: Uh-oh…
Dominique: to summarize. Yeah. So looking back over 100 episodes, six years of massive shifts in this field, how would you say, you know, in a few words your personal approach to this work has evolved?
Melissa: Oh my goodness. If I think about where I was at Dialectic, we were sort of thinking about how we can help the folks with the boots on the ground.
We were the folks who were kind of maybe, you know, doing the consulting. I’m now boots on the ground, right? So I’m,
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: Really thinking about, like,
Dominique: Yeah…
Melissa: How do I take everything that I read, how do I take things that consultants might share, and how do I actually make that work, and how do I operationalize that?
Dominique: Mm-hmm.
Melissa: And I think, moving from sort of recommendation implementation, and even my own recommendations that I make, you know, I’m like, “Oh, I have to implement this.” I can see, you know, that it’s hard to make DEI commitments real. But, I think where I’m working on and I focus, you know, we’ve, really focusing on how can we create a culture,
Dominique: Mm
Melissa: Where we are, where people want to come here? I mean,
Dominique: Yeah …
Melissa: where this is a place where people want to come and where they want to stay. That we are known. My goal is that OVC is known as a place where we provide meaningful work, which I know we already do, but a meaningful work experience, and I think that’s when I know we’ve achieved sort of what we’re looking for.
And I think that we are sort of shifting the demographics, that we are creating access pathways for folks who have historically and continue to be underrepresented in veterinary medicine, and that folks stay, and that we retain folks. So, that doesn’t answer the question 100%. I think where I am is that I’m really focusing on how can I shift our system?
How can I sort of, you know, answer the call that I think maybe Black Lives Matter originally said? It was like, let’s identify where the gaps are,
Dominique: yep …
Melissa: how our little sphere has historically, and to this day made it difficult for certain folks to access the training, to access the experiences here, and then what do we need to do to, to shift that?
Dominique: Yeah.
Melissa: And you know, we’ve never had a DEI statement, and I always never felt like I could put one out just that would be authentic. But I still think, like, if folks come up to me and say, like, “Things have really changed here, and I really feel like we are moving in the right direction,” like, that to me is more valuable than any, you know, DEI statement that I could have come up with a few years ago.
So.
Dominique: Absolutely. Yeah.
Melissa: Yeah.
Dominique: Well, that’s… I think you’ve done a great job of summing that up, actually. The transition…
Melissa: oh.
Dominique: Yeah, the transition from training to boots on the ground, a transition from a focus on maybe finding the right words to actually trying to create the culture that supports inclusion and access for a broader range of people.
That’s, you know, I think sort of encapsulates this journey that we’ve been on. And you know, the work of building workplaces where people really belong and thrive and do their best work is obviously not over, and we’re gonna keep having these conversations, and as a podcast, we’re obviously gonna keep bringing the researchers and practitioners and leaders who are doing that real gritty work on the front lines to talk about it.
I wanna thank you, Dr. Melissa Horne, for being here with us, and for starting this podcast, which I think has brought immense value certainly to my life and practice and to those of our listeners. So thank you so much for being here and sharing some of these insights with us.
Melissa: Well, thank you so much for having me, and you know, it’s amazing to see where we started and where you’ve taken it as well. And I think, you know, if you follow the trajectory of this podcast and if you go back and look at the episodes you can see how this podcast also mirrors and mimics sort of where DEI has, has moved from, you know, when we first started out in 2020 to where we are now.
And I think if we continue to look forward you’ll be leading the way, right? Showing where this area of work is going. So thank you for the care that you put into this and the guests that you bring on and your leadership in this space as well.
Dominique: Yeah. And thanks to the amazing guests who continue to agree to, to be on the podcast. And, time after time just blow me away with their insights and all of the things that they’re willing to share and to help other people put it into practice. So anyway, here’s to 100 more great conversations. And if you like what you’re hearing on Just One Q, we deeply appreciate a quick follow or a review wherever you get your podcasts. I’m Dominique Attrell. Thank you so much for listening, and see you next time on Just One Q.
Melissa holds a PhD in Black History from Rutgers University. Specializing in the history of social justice movements, Melissa’s research focuses on the historic systems of racism and oppression within historically Black universities and colleges and the ways in which students and faculty have organized movements to subvert and challenge these systems.
Working through the complexities of diversity, equity & inclusion training requires open and consistent dialogue on all parts. We want to learn from you, too.
Do you want to be featured as a guest to share what you know about diversity in the workplace? Do you know someone else who would make a good fit? Do you have feedback about how we can improve our podcast in the future?
See how easy it is to activate soft skills in your organization. Soft skills training on 3 key topics: Leadership, Belonging and Collaboration.